^^^^
I was able to find the 1940 United States Census record for Anthony Todaro. It also lists Joe Todaro Sr.'s mother, Sarah, as well as his siblings. See https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:K7SQ-F96. Unfortunately, I couldn't find immigration/travel records for either Anthony or Sarah, who according to the census were both born in Italy. I'm curious why Sarah's name was anglicized from, I presume, Sara--all of her and Anthony's children listed in the census do not have Italian first names except for the youngest, Salvatore.

FamilySearch isn't going to cut it, unless I can find an immigration/travel record for either of the two Salvatore Todaros.