The critics were out to destroy it as soon as it was announced. The Godfather got many bad reviews, and the average rating for Goodfellas when it came out was 2 stars out of 4 by critics. While I don't think this movie will be as good as either, especially the greatest movie of all time Godfather, it may turn out to be a fan favorite as more people see it and make up their own minds. I have not gone to see it yet but plan to. My one apprehension is Travolta as Gotti. I will give it look to make up my mind.