1. Amato
2. Accardo
3. Pranno
4. ??? (not Gags)
5. Palermo
6. Guy Cervone (Toodoped's new West Side chart has a pic; really looks like him)
7. ??? (Nuccio?)
8. ??? (think this may actually be Nuccio)
9. Cerone (Fosco implied it wasn't Ricca)
10. Di Varco!!!!***

***Came across a contemporary pic of Di Varco a while back, and instantly noticed the resemblance. Ear lobes and chin are spot on, and it makes sense, as I can recall Fosco asking someone on ANP which guy they thought was Di Varco. I believe the guess was #7.

Here's Di Varco at what looks like a country club: