That is 100% Lucky Luciano and he did have tattoos.

This is a quote from Lucky Luciano: The Real and the Fake Gangster by Tim Newark.

"The FBI gave a physical description of Luciano in 1947 as five feet nine and three-quarter inches tall, 145 to 150 pounds, slim, wavy, heavy dark brown hair turning gray, dark chestnut eyes, and tattooed on both arms.

Supposedly one of his tattoos said 'Lucky'