Thanks for the input AntSamuel.

From the research that I've done this is my best guess.

Mike Miranda, Joe Adonis, Rocco Pellegrino, Gaetano Ricci, Ciro Terranova, Tony Strollo, Ritchie Boiardo, Willie Moretti

I believe Mike Coppola replaced Terranova in the 30's. Jimmy Angelina and Anthony Carfano became captains later on as well.

I'm pretty sure Vincent Alo was under Joey A and replaced him when Joey A went to Italy in the late 50's.