So again you hang on an excerpt and don't know what the full obit said. Go find that and that'll settle one small detail. Let me ask you this do you think Saul Kane hated Phil for flipping? Did Phil's testimony hurt Saul Kane in any way? You questioning everything Phil has said based on this isn't enough. So again even if I were to concede this (which I'm not) what else has Phil lied about? Take your time and enlighten everyone.