Hey Mikey! Yes, I agree with you on Toto's. Not a bad pie. I know we are going off topic from pizza but we are from the same area and I want to share a place with you that you may or may not know about.
It is by far the best Italian meal I have had outside of my own families kitchen.
Located in Occidental, CA about an hour and half drive up north close to the Russian River is a place called Negri's. It's a beautiful drive, antique stores to check out along the way if you like that kind of thing (my wife and I do) and the food is excellent.
Don't pay no mind to the Yelp reviews..yelpers don't know shit.
http://www.negrisrestaurant.com/