No, definitely was Louis Ferrante. It came out in ~1994. I'd imagine the distro was very limited...would have hoped someone would have put it one the web by now, but cannot find it for the life of me.
I did like the Fun Loving Criminals though, totally forgot about their existence until now...thx for the reminder!
That song was the first time I ever heard about John Gotti! Maybe 1997 or 98 I think?
