I dont know what criteria you are using, it seems to be your favorites which is ok because typically fans vote for their all stars in sports but I dont see some of these guys being an all star:

Roy Demeo: Whacked by own family, physcopath, drug dealer, brought a shit ton of heat. I could go on and on and on and on but nuff said

MAd Sam: Whacked by own family, same as Demeo, phscopath, and on and on and on

Jimmy Brown fialla- Good capo yes but this is the same guy who basically double crossed the Gambino administration

Salvie Testa: Whacked by own family

Mirra: Responsible for the Donnie Brasco fiasco, if anyone is far from an all star its him. Also whacked by own family.

I can see Neil and Accardo being on this list but when your own family whacks you that means they had a reason to do so and you are not an all star.