Everything I read on the internet said that the tomato juice thing doesn't work as well as the peroxide/baking soda/dish soap combo. And after smelling her and cleaning the tub out for the Nth time, it was worth the $40 to bring her to Petco. The problem was that she got sprayed right in the face, so we had to be very careful near her eyes with everything we used. Plus, she kept rubbing her damn snout all over the furniture!