Honestly Kly, Utley should have been the MVP. No question about it, had he gotten some better pitching and had hitters ahead of him actually get on base (is this the place for a "Jimmy Rollins is overrated" debate?), it could be a whole different story.

As far as Matsui winning the MVP, it was his performance in Game 6 that really sealed it. Otherwise, it could just have easily been Burnett had he not blown up in Game 5; Jeter, had he gotten a clutch hit instead of a GIDP at the end of Game 5; etc. etc. etc.