Originally Posted By: The Hollywood Finochio
Agreed about the Sonny and Luca points, they should have certainly figured in the flashbacks. My god, the things Luca is alleged to have done in the book would have burned the screen. Sonny tells the Don in the book at that he witnessed the murder of Fanucci...could have been interesting.

To see the events in Filomena's story on screen would be something... Also the killing of the Al Capone's henchmen, the killing of Don Alioto and the rest. Luca with his reputation is never seen killing anyone. And yeah, the dispute between Sonny and his father, entering the business, commanding his regime after the assassination attempt on the Don would really be worth watching.


Originally Posted By: Sicilian Babe
Why was Vito's return to Sicily unrealistic?? And why was his childhood unrealistic?

The plot is kinda forced and cliched. The young Vito is weak and considered mentally challanged, his brother is also murdered, his mother goes to Don Ciccio to beg him to let him live and when he refuse she sacrifes herself to allow Vito to escape with gunmen with luparas running after him. And of course, he comes for revenge after decades. A flashback from his childhood in Sicily is necessary but they should have left it simple like in the novel.