Interesting discussion on the Colts message boards...
Peyton Manning is more clutch than Tom Brady when 4 or more points are needed.
Let me say that I genuinely like Peyton. But there is no way he is more clutch than Brady in any situation.
Super Bowl appearances: Brady 4, Peyton 1
Super Bowl wins: Brady 3, Peyton 1
With the exeption of 2007, Peyton had always had a ton more skill positions at his disposal than Brady, which makes Brady's feats all the more impressive.
Peyton came up short when the Colts had more talent than just about anyone else except in 2006. Brady took his team and scored the winning drive with less than 2 minutes in two separate Super Bowls. Brady was 1:00 short of finishing a perfect season, which was not made imperfect by any huge mistake by Brady.
