Well, your impression of the food was spot on. Certainly good, but definitely not great. They love to advertise "originally from the Bronx" because I think that people then assume that it's "authentic Italian", if you know what I mean.

You want GREAT food? You have to try this place Il Portico. Not only is the food out of this world, but the service is excellent as well. The carpaccio is wonderful, and even though it's not on the menu, they will make Spaghetti Carbonara on request. I've also enjoyed the filet mignon. And they have the most delightful tartufo I've ever eaten.