Not as bad as originally thought (better than HUDSON HAWK anyway). Ok, first of all, who was the genius to cast Geena Davis as a pirate? If one thing is true in this universe, its that Geena Davis is NOT and can NOT play a pirate! Matthew Modine I'll cut a little more slack as he was passable as a thief/pirate.
As for the film, a decent amount of action but by the Third Act it's tiresome. It should have and could have been cut by about 10-15 minutes and those fights at the end hurt the film rather than helped it. Now I'm waiting on CUTTHROAT ISLAND 2: THE AFRICAN ADVENTURE
