Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I certainly admire your passion for convaying yours. Of course, Micheal's Charecter in the GDF Returnes book is a bit differnt than in the film,but I believe Wingardener did well in his own right. No one can easily duplicate the charecters like Coppola and Puzo did, because they are NOT Coppola or Puzo.So,as an auther,you do the best you can with your own ideas. So I have to ask: Who do you think should have written GDF Returns?