Winegardner's spin on The Corleone's and The Godfather plain out sucks!

Anyone who read GF Returns, and is a true GF fan immedeatly recognizes the fact that Mr. Winegardner did NOT do his homework when writing his book. Mr. Winegardner had absolutely no clue as to how to properly portray Puzo's characters and as far as I am concerned Mr. Winegardner's GF stories have absolutly no merit whatsoever and do an injustice to the story and the characters that Mario Puzo created. So many things could have been done with the direction of the GF Returns and the characters, but obviously Winegarner had a totally different idea and without doing his homework created personalities of the GF characters that were no where near what the original characters were like.

The synopsis/excerp from this new GF book does not excite me one bit.


There are several members on these boards who, without question, could have done 1000 times better in writing another GF book than this pezzanovante did with GF Returns.

Winegardner's GF Returns should


Don Cardi