Originally Posted by JCrusher
There is no evidence to suggest Fredo knew it was going y be a hit. Fredo is portrayed as stupid and harmless. Let’s be honest what did murdering Fredo accomplish besides causing a ruftvin his immediate family(Kay and Anthony)and causing Michael to be haunted by it for the rest of his life. Doesn’t seem worth it especially considering even Mike said “he knows Toth misled him and he didn’t know they were foing to try and kill me”


It may follow more from the book than the first movie, but Michael is supposed to be a rationalist, and in this instance he's trapped by his nature. The principle that's been instilled in him is that when an enemy reveals himself he must be destroyed, and Michael lacks the ability to adjust for that. So, Fredo must die because Roth must die, Roth must die because Barzini, et al. died. It's self-activating.


"All of these men were good listeners; patient men."