Originally Posted by dsd
Originally Posted by jace
I don't trust Henry Hill's account of anything. He his the one and only source for the killing. I think they may killed a person, probably a guy in the drug rackets over a dumb bar fight, but I don't think it was anyone made, or that DeSimone was tricked into thinking he was going to get made in order to kill him. I wonder if Henry Hill's book version of events (Which differ from the movie) are in his original briefings from when he began to rat? In [i]the book I think DeSimone killed the so-called Billy Bats 2 weeks after the "shine box" argument in a different bar. [/i]

[/i][b][/b][u][/u][i]

Been awhile since I last saw the film but isn't Batts bar beating , a different day from the shinebox scene??


Nah it’s the same evening in the film but in the book (irl too?) batts was killed weeks and maybe months after the initial dust up.