Sure thing Turnbull spot on! indeed

My only debating point! is if Michael had died in the Tahoe shooting I doubt Tom or any one would have even suspected that Fredo “conspired in his brother's murder”

Fredo still would not have “qualified to be Don” even as a figurehead but you are right about the “constant theme in the movies and in the novel is that greed and thirst for revenge motivate and undo stupid people”

Well, not just people like Paulie, Carlo, Fabrizio, Tessio and Fredo though
Michael was nearly undone himself with Roth

Paulie was a dead man either way same as Tessio Once a traitor always a traitor However....

What would your take be?
  • if Paulie had not called in sick on the day of Vito's attempted murder
  • say if Paulie had 'tried' heroically to save Vito, putting his own life on the line but couldn't and ended up with 'non-life'! threatening injuries
  • Paulie may have got away with it? at least been given the benefit of the doubt?
  • ”something in it” for Paulie - obvious 'promises' 'rewards' only money