Forums21
Topics42,415
Posts1,060,537
Members10,349
|
Most Online911 May 23rd, 2024
|
|
|
Who knew Fredo's treason?
#632716
02/01/12 06:46 PM
02/01/12 06:46 PM
|
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,528 AZ
Turnbull
OP
|
OP
![](/ubb/5stars10k.gif)
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,528
AZ
|
When Michael returned from Havana, he asked Rocco and Neri to leave the room before querying Tom about Fredo. Michael assumed Tom knew about Fredo’s treason because he said, “Tell him I know Roth misled him…” But evidently, Michael didn’t want R&N to know about it—at least at that point. That would be consistent with his character as a controller and as one who kept all info close to himself.
Later, when Fredo and Michael had it out in the boathouse, Michael had Neri wait outside, unseen by Fredo. Probably he did that to make Fredo think they were alone, and to encourage him to tell all. It’s also possible he wanted Neri to be ready to defend him in case Fredo made a move against him—not totally inconceivable given Fredo’s treason with Roth. Neri would have known by that time that Fredo and Michael were on the outs because Fredo was no longer at the compound. But, do you think at that point he knew why? I can’t dismiss the possibility that Michael hadn’t told Neri exactly why—but wanted him to overhear Fredo’s treason from his own lips so that Neri could be that much more motivated to kill Fredo at the appropriate time.
Also, when Connie got on her knees and beseeched Michael to forgive Fredo during Mama’s wake, do you think she knew that Fredo had betrayed Michael to Roth? Michael wouldn’t have told her, and Fredo may not have told her everything. Also, she prefaced her plea by confessing that “I hated you…until I realized that you were just being strong for all of us.” She wanted back in. Do you think that her plea for Fredo was a ploy to come back into the compound and be taken care of?
Ntra la porta tua lu sangu � sparsu, E nun me mporta si ce muoru accisu... E s'iddu muoru e vaju mparadisu Si nun ce truovo a ttia, mancu ce trasu.
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: Turnbull]
#632721
02/01/12 07:21 PM
02/01/12 07:21 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 15,022 Texas
olivant
|
![](/ubb/5stars10k.gif)
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 15,022
Texas
|
Well TB, there's alot there. First, I have never bought into the Micahel as controller theme of so many posts. Michael was the head of an organization where, every day, being murdered was a real possibility. So, Michael managed his environment to minimize that possibility. I don't find that management exceptional.
Who knew about Fredo's betrayal? Well, how did Tom find out? I'm sure Michael didn't tell him. Besides, why did Tom think that Fredo was in NY? Why would he know about Fredo's whereabouts in the first place? Or, if he did know, why would he only think he was in NY? Why wouldn't he know for sure if he knew at all?
I don't think Fredo was ever a physical threat to Micahel. I can't remember where Neri was physically located at the time of Fredo's confession. Also, I don't think Neri had any qualms about murdering or needed any motivation to murder anybody.
As far as Connie goes, I don't think she knew. That Fredo had been a stranger to the compound after Cuba (I guess he was), Connie was aware and, like anyone, would figure that something had gone drastically wrong in Fredo's and Michael's relationship. I also think that Connie had been back in the compound for awhile. Her statement about hating Michael I understood as being her feeling in the past.
Last edited by olivant; 02/01/12 07:23 PM.
"Generosity. That was my first mistake." "Experience must be our only guide; reason may mislead us." "Instagram is Twitter for people who can't read."
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: Turnbull]
#632725
02/01/12 08:16 PM
02/01/12 08:16 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 5,325 MI
Lilo
|
![](/ubb/5stars.gif)
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 5,325
MI
|
The aside to Tom is a offhand admission that Tom is not as stupid as Michael thinks he is. It also could indicate that Fredo had already tried calling Tom and Tom told Michael or Michael would just figure Fredo would get in touch with Tom.
In the boathouse I still think that Fredo still had a tiny chance (perhaps a 1 in a 1,000,000,000 chance) to escape the full force of Michael's wrath if he had almost literally turned on his back and bared his throat. But no, he lost his temper, showed his deep resentments and also revealed he knew more about Roth's plans than he had let on. That did it.
I don't think Michael or Tom or any of the employees would have told Connie anything. But she's been around; she can pick up cues, especially from people she grew up with. I don't think she had any idea of what Fredo had actually done or the fact that Michael was planning his murder. She just wanted things to be good again. She knew her brothers were angry and wanted to make peace.
"When the snows fall and the white winds blow, the lone wolf dies but the pack survives." Winter is Coming
Now this is the Law of the Jungle—as old and as true as the sky; And the wolf that shall keep it may prosper, but the wolf that shall break it must die. As the creeper that girdles the tree-trunk, the Law runneth forward and back; For the strength of the Pack is the Wolf, and the strength of the Wolf is the Pack.
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: Turnbull]
#632741
02/01/12 09:46 PM
02/01/12 09:46 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 15,022 Texas
olivant
|
![](/ubb/5stars10k.gif)
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 15,022
Texas
|
.
Who knew about Fredo's betrayal? Well, how did Tom find out? I'm sure Michael didn't tell him. Besides, why did Tom think that Fredo was in NY? Why would he know about Fredo's whereabouts in the first place? Or, if he did know, why would he only think he was in NY? Why wouldn't he know for sure if he knew at all?
I tried to address all those questions here: http://www.gangsterbb.net/threads/ubbthr...true#Post472494 Well, I checked out the link. It prompts me to ask why Michael thought Tom would know Fredo's whereabouts. Of course, there's no indication why Tom would answer a question about Fredo by telling Michael about Roth. Also, I think that in the evident confusion that followed on the heels of Castro's imminent invasion of Havana, Fredo escaped just like many Americans escaped by obtaining passage on a boat. I don't think there was any time for Fredo to arrange passage with friends. Heck, Michael barely escaped.
"Generosity. That was my first mistake." "Experience must be our only guide; reason may mislead us." "Instagram is Twitter for people who can't read."
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: olivant]
#632792
02/02/12 11:09 AM
02/02/12 11:09 AM
|
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,528 AZ
Turnbull
OP
|
OP
![](/ubb/5stars10k.gif)
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,528
AZ
|
It prompts me to ask why Michael thought Tom would know Fredo's whereabouts. Of course, there's no indication why Tom would answer a question about Fredo by telling Michael about Roth. Also, I think that in the evident confusion that followed on the heels of Castro's imminent invasion of Havana, Fredo escaped just like many Americans escaped by obtaining passage on a boat. I don't think there was any time for Fredo to arrange passage with friends. Heck, Michael barely escaped.
Well, that's the thing that intrigued me about that scene, and prompted my earlier thread. Michael just assumed Tom would know Fredo's whereabouts because he knew or surmised that Fredo would be close to Tom, and that in a panic, he'd call Tom first. Don Cardi posted a convincing bit of made-up dialog to that point in the thread I referenced. Now, that raises a couple of other intereting points (or at least I think they're interesting): First,Tom surely knew that Michael wouldn't give Fredo a pass, and that when Michael "forgave" Fredo, it was only temporarily until Mama died. Do you think Tom ever contemplated warning Fredo that he was in a trap? Second, Michael was practically frantic to get Fredo on the plane with him in Havana. But once he was back in Nevada, he just told Tom to "get word" to Fredo, when in fact he could have had Fredo snatched off the streets of NY and hauled to Nevada. Why the sudden shift?
Ntra la porta tua lu sangu � sparsu, E nun me mporta si ce muoru accisu... E s'iddu muoru e vaju mparadisu Si nun ce truovo a ttia, mancu ce trasu.
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: Turnbull]
#632801
02/02/12 01:41 PM
02/02/12 01:41 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 11,468 With Geary in Fredo's Brothel
dontomasso
Consigliere to the Stars
|
Consigliere to the Stars
![](/ubb/5stars10k.gif)
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 11,468
With Geary in Fredo's Brothel
|
A good deal of this goes back to my belief that Tom gets a bad rap on the boards.
Just as Tom intuited the "secret" Neri regime, he also intuited that there would be an attempt on Michael's life...at Vito's funeral he matter of factly asks "Do you know how they're gonna come after you? And then..."I always thought it would be Clemenza."
As for Fredo, I believe Fredo contacted Tom from New York. Considering the Castro takeover and the escapes by Michael Fredo and Roth, Tom had to know something was up when Fredo called from NY, and being the non-Sicilian, he evaded Michael's questions about Fredo's whereabouts because in his heart he knew that Fredo was a dead man. As for Connie, it is unclear that she knew what Fredo did to deserve to be killed, but by the time of III, it is clear she knew because when Michael tells her he went to confesion, the firt thing she talks about is Michael's greatest wrong -- fratricide. So she glosses it over with the fiction about "poor Fredo drowning."
"Io sono stanco, sono imbigliato, and I wan't everyone here to know, there ain't gonna be no trouble from me..Don Corleone..Cicc' a port!"
"I stood in the courtroom like a fool."
"I am Constanza: Lord of the idiots."
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: Turnbull]
#632818
02/02/12 04:03 PM
02/02/12 04:03 PM
|
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 773 Pittsburgh, PA
The Last Woltz
Underboss
|
Underboss
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 773
Pittsburgh, PA
|
Now, that raises a couple of other intereting points (or at least I think they're interesting):
First,Tom surely knew that Michael wouldn't give Fredo a pass, and that when Michael "forgave" Fredo, it was only temporarily until Mama died. Do you think Tom ever contemplated warning Fredo that he was in a trap?
Second, Michael was practically frantic to get Fredo on the plane with him in Havana. But once he was back in Nevada, he just told Tom to "get word" to Fredo, when in fact he could have had Fredo snatched off the streets of NY and hauled to Nevada. Why the sudden shift? I think it would have been out of character for Tom to contemplate warning Fredo. For all the "non-Sicilian" jibes thrown his way, Tom certainly seemed unmoved when Tessio asked for mercy. His ultimate loyalty, whether out of love, fear, or jealousy, was to Michael. As to the "sudden shift," I don't find it implausible. In Cuba, Michael had just discovered Fredo's treachery and was, admittedly, heartbroken. I think, in his emotional state, he hadn't decided what to do about it. His urgency was a combination of his agitation, the chaotic scene around him, and his desire to keep Fredo close until he decided on a course of action. Later, Michael has cooled down and his anger has harded, but he still needs to keep tabs on Fredo. So he adopts a different tactic to try to reel him back in.
"A man in my position cannot afford to be made to look ridiculous!"
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: JCrusher]
#633747
02/08/12 02:23 PM
02/08/12 02:23 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 15,022 Texas
olivant
|
![](/ubb/5stars10k.gif)
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 15,022
Texas
|
I always assumed that Fredo's betrayal was common knowledge amongst the Family & the likes of Neri, but Michael wanted to deal with it by himself as much as he could, due to the extreme nature of treachery by an actual family member. Obviously any soldier or capo couldn't kill Fredo Corleone without approval, even if they did happen to find him. Connie could have known all & still been willing to forgive Fredo, Tom would have been waiting for his Don's orders.
The fact that the Don of the Family wanted to take such a careful & hands-on approach in dealing with this particular traitor emphasised: - just how serious Fredo's betrayal was; - how deeply Michael was hurt by it.
I don't think there's much else in the detail.
I kind of saw it a different way. First of all i dont think Fredo "betrayal" was that horrible. everybody with half a brain knows fredo was good hearted and din't want his family members hurt. sure he was stupid and jealous but he wasn't evil enough to kill a member of his family. Hell even Al neri who was one of the most emotionless hitmen in the Godfather kind of had a soft spot for fredo since you can tell he wasn't thrilled about having to kill him I tend to agree. While he could be truculent when pressed, I don't think Fredo had larceny or worse in his heart. Michael's decision to murder Fredo was based on his outrage over Fredo's outburst. Michael considered that outburst a function of Fredo's unmitigated stupidity and that stupidity is what really governed Michael's decision. Also, I agree about Neri. In a perfect world, Neri would have given Fredo a pass.
"Generosity. That was my first mistake." "Experience must be our only guide; reason may mislead us." "Instagram is Twitter for people who can't read."
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: dontomasso]
#633951
02/09/12 12:36 PM
02/09/12 12:36 PM
|
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,528 AZ
Turnbull
OP
|
OP
![](/ubb/5stars10k.gif)
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,528
AZ
|
I believe he even lied to Mike in the boathouse about not knowing it was going to be a hit. Fredo was a clear and present danger to the family and he had to go just like any traitor. Fredo knew the Feds had Pentangeli, and that the Senate lawyer, Questadt, belonged to Roth. Probably he knew that because Roth told him. Had he passed on that info to Michael at any time before the boathouse meeting, he would have been immensely helpful to his brother, and might have earned a pass. He didn't. That tells me that, even after Havana, Fredo was still intent on hurting his brother.
Ntra la porta tua lu sangu � sparsu, E nun me mporta si ce muoru accisu... E s'iddu muoru e vaju mparadisu Si nun ce truovo a ttia, mancu ce trasu.
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: dontomasso]
#635753
02/20/12 01:38 PM
02/20/12 01:38 PM
|
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 1,466 No. Virginia
mustachepete
Special
|
Special
Underboss![](/ubb/1star.gif)
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 1,466
No. Virginia
|
Can anyone think of anything "sweet" he ever did? He picked people up at the airport. There's nothing sweeter than that.
"All of these men were good listeners; patient men."
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: olivant]
#635927
02/21/12 03:38 PM
02/21/12 03:38 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 11,468 With Geary in Fredo's Brothel
dontomasso
Consigliere to the Stars
|
Consigliere to the Stars
![](/ubb/5stars10k.gif)
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 11,468
With Geary in Fredo's Brothel
|
D, I agree with your perception. I also agree that it was Fredo who arranged Michael's greeting. Afterall, Fredo handled the hotel side of the business. I also think that Michael cold have adminished Fredo in private instead of in public as he did. There was no need to humiliate Fredo like that. Well Oli, no one ever accused Michael of being sweet.
"Io sono stanco, sono imbigliato, and I wan't everyone here to know, there ain't gonna be no trouble from me..Don Corleone..Cicc' a port!"
"I stood in the courtroom like a fool."
"I am Constanza: Lord of the idiots."
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: Mark]
#636010
02/21/12 09:26 PM
02/21/12 09:26 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 3,068
JCrusher
Underboss
|
Underboss![](/ubb/3stars.gif)
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 3,068
|
but the film made it pretty clear taht fredo wouldn't harm anybody even if he wanted to. Didn't he harm Michael by betraying him to Roth, and after that not telling him that Pentangeli had survived and that the Senate lawyer, Questadt, belonged to Roth? Maybe he meant that Fredo actually administering direct physical violence? Right Mark. Also sure fredo lied about the lawyer im niot saying that wasn't a mistake but we all know fredo didn't know it was gonna be a hit.
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: JCrusher]
#636116
02/22/12 04:34 PM
02/22/12 04:34 PM
|
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,528 AZ
Turnbull
OP
|
OP
![](/ubb/5stars10k.gif)
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,528
AZ
|
but we all know fredo didn't know it was gonna be a hit. Do we all know that? One of the longest-running discussions on this board is whether or not Fredo knew it was gonna be a hit, or if he really didn't, what did he know or think was going to happen?
Ntra la porta tua lu sangu � sparsu, E nun me mporta si ce muoru accisu... E s'iddu muoru e vaju mparadisu Si nun ce truovo a ttia, mancu ce trasu.
|
|
|
Re: Who knew Fredo's treason?
[Re: Turnbull]
#636117
02/22/12 04:43 PM
02/22/12 04:43 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 3,068
JCrusher
Underboss
|
Underboss![](/ubb/3stars.gif)
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 3,068
|
but we all know fredo didn't know it was gonna be a hit. Do we all know that? One of the longest-running discussions on this board is whether or not Fredo knew it was gonna be a hit, or if he really didn't, what did he know or think was going to happen? it would totally be against character for all of a sudden fredo to be a vicious hitman/organizer. i mean throughout the series fredo has been portrayed as yes stupid weak but he is the most sensitive and less violent. Yes he was jealous but ther is a difference between being jealous and then acting it out through rage. I mean even Mike knew that fredo didn't know it was a hit but at that point mike would kill anybody even if they said hello to him lol
|
|
|
|