I haven't read the Sicilian, but for those who have read it I want to ask this: does this novel specifically state that it takes place in 1950? Or is this just presumed because of its main character's real-life counterpart?

Yes, Sonny. "Book 1" or "Part 1" (I forget the exact terminology) opens in Sicily 1950. It's actually printed that way. I'll try to take a cell pic or something.

Here you go, Sonny. From the first edition copy.

Bummer. Just when I thought we could dismiss the Sicilian as an argument for the date of Michael's return, it pulled me back in.

I want to torment Puzo's soul for leaving us with such a frustratingly confusing timeline.

I had a feeling it would be bad news for you .

Anyway, thanks for showing it to me.

No problem. But you really should read the book, Sonny. It doesn't add anything to Michael's character development, per se, but Puzo manages to paint a beautiful picture of Western Sicily. I honestly thought it was his most thoughtful book. And even though the ending is a given because of the Giuliano character's real life demise, it's hard not to feel bad for the guy because of the character who ultimately betrays him (in Puzo's fictionalized account, anyway). And the meeting at the end of the book between Vito and a returning Michael is a must read for any fan of the franchise.

It's great book! Actually I think I read this one first because I was interested in Giuliano, and that was how I discovered The Godfather.