Scott could go next, his popularity is really waning. There is only so much "decent voice, bad packaging" that can go around.

But the Anthony love? I don't understand it. Anthony (or Clay Lite as some like to call him!) has a TON of fans. I think he is endearing to some because he overcame the language barrier; the tracheotomy barrier; some of teen set may think he is cute because he looks a little like Nick Carter of the Backstreet Boys. He IS a likeable personality.

But wait...did I mention vocals? Decent but nothing to write home about. And in my opinion oozes NO charisma.

But case in point - a guy I work with is a rabid Anthony fan. Thinks he should go on to win this whole thing!

But I must mention also this same coworker was pushing for Johnny Red (the crooner) last year so there ya go. What motivates America can be very different depending on who you ask.