Well I enjoyed the story too, but its not the only reason to dig or hate any film. Besides, good acting and direction can be quite useless if the screenplay and especially the story SUCK.

I still think SIN CITY is slightly a better picture(can't decide between ***1/2 or **** out of 5) because of ambition, visual style, and creativity.

Still, CONSTANTINE was a good movie, which we both can agree on.