I won't admit that Scarface is overrated. On this board, maybe. But the people who already come to this board are fans already (some are at least). In the real world I don't feel Scarface gets enough respect as it deserves. Nor do I feel Pacino gets enough respect for his role as Tony Montana. Substance this and substance that, in my book Scarface is more entertaining than Carlito's Way. Read into it anyway you want from directing to soundtrack to character development yada, yada yada, you will not convince me that Carlito's Way is superior to Scarface