The best I ever seen in person:

High School: Joe McKnight. McKnight and John Curtis Christian came to play Hoover High (suburb of Birmingham) in I think McKnight's senior year. He flat out torched Hoover (who was ranked #1 by USA Today at the time) for 70 yards rushing and 2 big TD's receiving (134 yards receiving) and they won 28-14.

College: Either Peyton Manning or Julio Jones.

Never been to a pro game so I have no opinion there.