Thanks to Pogo the Clown

Colombo Family:

Likely candidates for the 1951 and the 1954-57 ceremonies:
Joseph Colombo
Carmine “Junior” Persico
Joseph “Crazy Joe” Gallo
Lawrence “Larry” Gallo
Joseph “Joe Jelly” Gioeli
John “Sonny” Franzese
Joseph "Joe Yack" Yacovelli
Anthony “Abby Shots” Abbatemarco
Salvatore “Sally Pro” Profaci
Charles “Charlie Moose” Panarella
Benedetto "Benny" Aloi
Vincent “Vinny” Aloi
James 'Jimmy Ski' Scianna
Anthony 'Tony Ski' Scianna

Bonanno Family:

1957:
Vito DeFilippo


Likely candidates for the 1954-57 ceremonies.
Carmine “The Cigar” Galante
Philip “Rusty” Rastelli
John "Johnny Burns" Morales
Frank “Musso” Mari
Michael Adamo
John Aquaro
Nicholas "Nicky Cigars/Glasses" Marangello
Stefano “Stevie Beefs” Cannone
Thomas “Smitty” D’Angelo
James D’Angelo
Salvatore “Sally Fruits” Farrugia
Joseph “Little Joe” Notaro
Peter Notaro
Michael “Mimi” Sabella
Dominick 'Little Mimi' Sabella
Armand “Mondo” Pollastrino
Michael “Mikey Z” Zaffarano
Joseph “Bayonne Joe” Zicarelli
Angelo Presenzano
Frank Presenzano
Sorreno Tartamella
Antonio Badalamenti
Samuel “Hank” Perrone
Carl Simari
Peter Cinquemani
Antonio Messina
Joseph Messina
Salvatore Bruno
Michael Cosenza
Russell Andaloro
Antonio Cacciopo
Giuseppe Titone
Philip “Phil Lucky” Giaccone - ?


1968:
Vincenzo Asaro

Gambino Family:

Likely candidates for the 1950, 1953 and 1954-1957 ceremonies.
Paul “Big Paul” Castellano
Aniello "Niel" Dellacroce
Joseph “Joe” N. Gallo
Frank “Frankie Loc” LoCascio
Steven Armone
Joseph “Joe Piney” Armone
James "Jimmy Brown" Failla
Anthony “Little Tony” Carminiti
Stephen "Steven Coogan" Grammauta
Salvatore "Toddo" Aurello
Louis “Louie” DiBono
Joseph "Joe" Arcuri
Vincent “Bozzi” DeCicco
Anthony Scotto
Mario Traina
Frank Corbi


1960:
Anthony “Nino” Gaggi

Lucchese Family:


1954-1957:
Frank Borelli

Genovese Family:


1957:
Frank Cacciatore (sponsored by Generoso DelDuca)
Joseph “Taddo” DeMarco (sponsored by Generoso DelDuca)
-Separate ceremony
Joseph Pagano (sponsored by Joseph Valachi) (Could have been in 1958)


1954-1957:
Vincent “Vinny Bruno” Mauro (sponsored by Joe Valachi)
Pasquale “Pat” Pagano (sponsored by Joe Valachi)
Fiore “Fury” Siano (sponsored by Joe Valachi)


Likely candidates for the 1954-57 ceremonies:
Vincent “The Chin” Gigante
Mario Gigante
Dominick “Baldy Dom” Cantarino
Dominick “Dom the Sailor” DeQuarto
Dominick “Fat Dom” Alongi
Lawrence "Little Larry/Fab" Dentico
Frank “Farby” Serpico
Thomas “Tommy” Lombardi
Anthony “Tony Boy” Boiardo
Joseph "Joe the Indian" Polverino
Anthony “Little Pussy” Russo
Thomas “Tommy Murphy” Pecora
Timothy “Timmy Murphy” Pecora
James “Jimo” Calabrese
Ralph “Spud” Vaccaro
Peter “Pete the Bull” Landusco
John “Johnny Cokes” Ladieri
Carl “Leash” Scalesa
Louis “Lucky” Percello
Louis “Lou Red” Gatto
Joseph “Joey” Miniscalco
Alphonse “Allie Boy” Cuomo
Nicholas Russo
FNU “Lay Lay” Cecere
Victor Pisauro
Angelo “Chippo” Chieppa
Angelo Sica
FNU “5 Brothers” LNU
FNU “Joe Black” LNU


1967:
James “Jimmy Nap” Napoli
Guiseppe “Joseph” Sabato