I think it should have been up to the states to decide.
I have a problem with nine lawyers being able to make a decision that affects over 300 million citizens.
I have had a change of heart since the Utah Bans Gay Marriage thread (partly from a conversation with my dad) I agree with this, leave it up to the State. Though I think differently than some on this "issue" and rights I feel all individuals should have 9 lawyers should not have this much power over individual lives.