I used to wear an assortment of things (infrequently) in the '70s and 80's, but I honestly can't remember any one particular product that stood out in my mind. Nowadays, dinosaur that I am, I will wear just a little bit of English Leather.
I've always had an aversion to those really overpowering scents that can knock you out from a block away. I remember back in college (in 1973), I had a roommate that wore Brut. He let me try some, and I swear you could smell it in the next county! I also tried the aftershave that fateful evening, and it burned the ever-lovin' crap out of my skin. Never again - even if Joe Namath
did do commercials for that shit!
Yeah, as the saying goes: I wear English Leather, or I wear nothing at all.

Signor V.