Things to consider:

Gotti Jr
•He was a shit negociator who lost the ear of the Genovese family
•When the FBI raided his house he had a list of made men in his own family and in other families

Allie Boy
•Was caught speeding in his boat and when stopped the coast guard found a shotgun and handgun onboard


In my opinion Gotti Jr was more of an idiot, at least Allie boy got into college and waited as long as he could before ascending to the Colombo family leadership even if he only lasted a year at least he kept the family in good face and held some respect from the troops