I think this thread is still salvageable.. we could talk about the most interesting mugshots. I agree, Lucky's is pretty much literally the face of Cosa Nostra.

Gotti's 1990 mugshot where he's got a big smile is also unique... I'm not sure how they even allowed him, I think you're not supposed to laugh during photo ID (not sure about the US regulations at the time)
Sammy's too where he's looking down you can almost feel he's thinking of flipping or something. tongue

I also like Pitera's arrest day mugshots although those face wounds make him look like a serial killer with blood spattered on his face... which he was.

-I shot him a coupla' times.
-What's a couple?
-Hmm, more than a couple... Really I don't know the exact amount, maybe I shot him 10 times, 12 times?
-Maybe fifteen?
-Hmm, it could've been fifteen...

-Anthony "Gaspipe" Casso