Apples and oranges.
Rose was a fierce competitor. So's Jeter, and I've always liked the way that he carries himself. He's a great Yankee, and a great competitor, and when the Hall comes calling on the first ballot, it will be well deserved.
But when it comes to all-time, all-around shortstops, he's not even in the top five, maybe even top ten.
No argument on any of the above, where you put him on list if too ten Yankees?
