Top 5 - America's Requestw/ Jason Mraz
Round 1
B Alex "Sweater Weather"
B Jena "My Body"
B Caleb "Don't Wanna Miss a Thing"
B- Sam "Sing"
D Jess "Human"
ALEX was good, a fitting song. K: Could've soared; H: Popular sound
CALEB is better at belting than singing. J: Made it yours, goosies; H: Sing to audience, not camera; K: More feeling
Trio: Jena, Alex, Sam - "Best Day of My Life" (B)
JESS wasn't great, especially in lower register. H: Pitch issues but improved performance; J: Live in the song
SAM was okay, funky, a bit Zzz. K: Tough song; H: Need to be in the pocket, but something different
JENA's lower register was totally lost, but a decent stage performance (best of the lot). J: Own style now; H: You move, fun
Round 2
B+ Caleb "Still of The Night"
B+ Alex "Say Something"
B- Sam "How To Save a Life"
B- Jena "Valerie"
C- Jess "Summertime Sadness"
Duet: Caleb & Jess - "Beast of Burden" (B)
ALEX was strong as usual. H: Didn't give in to emotion, performance of the night; K: Beautiful
JENA's voice (nasally vibrato) I'm getting used to. K: Killer vocals; J: Not best one (tempo, arrangement)
SAM wasn't bad, but not a great night for him. J: Shaky beginning, goosies; H: Pitch issues, dynamics issues
JESS was lackluster, even showing full leg. H: Perfect song for you; K: Lean into it more; J: Dig in more performance wise
CALEB = RAWK! K: Killer; J: Crazy!; H: Fantastic
Overall
1 Alex
2 Caleb
3 Jena
4 Sam
5 Jess
Alex and Caleb were very close, but Alex is the better
singer. Jena edged out Sam with her stage presence. Jess, well, needs to go next.