the current alleged administration of the Lucchese family is pretty all-star'ish for the modern day. Not enough to keep them out of jail or their names out of indictments, but Miglore, Madonna, Crea, etc... all seem pretty low key, quiet, old timey. I wouldn't be surprised if they surpass the Gambinos as the 2nd most powerful family in New York in the next 5-10 years.

I can't think of a full hypothetical "all star" family but I'd definitely have Joe Todaro Sr. from Buffalo in there somewhere, and maybe John S------- as a soldier or even a Capo over a crew of guys who don't do any wet work - basically a family of a bunch of relatively quiet quai-legitimate earners and some tough, but not deranged soldiers to back them up