I saw Jesus Christ Superstar on Broadway back in the 70s. What a phenomenal play, yet the Church was originally against it, no? I think mostly because of the relationship between Jesus and Mary Magdalene. I would have enjoyed seeing Godspell, which I haven't seen since I was a kid.
The gentleman who runs my daughter's theater camp wrote a musical called "The 12", which about the lives of the apostles after Jesus's death. It was very good, but I'm not sure if it will make it to Broadway.