Originally Posted By: J Geoff

Still watching via DVR, but thought I should start the thread.

First impressions: Tyler is a bit annoying, JLo isn't too bad. But it's still early yet. wink

And this whole Jersey theme is killing me, after 10 years of them calling us New York, they're trying to bring in that "Jersey Shore" crap...


You mean....the Situation isn't a typical Jersyian/Yorker?

confused

Not like there's a difference or anything, right? tongue

EDIT - as for IDOL itself, technically Tyler is more qualified to judge singing than Simon Cowell, who's "credentials" amounted to boy bands and producing the WRESTLEMANIA album. Though to be fair, Cowell did co-found and run the Fanfare label so there's that.

Of course people didn't watch Cowell for his expertize. They watched him to be a dick, especially to the blooper reel-quality contestents. IDOL can' replace that.

And I guess this says something about J-Lo's current career that she's doing IDOL now.

Last edited by ronnierocketAGO; 01/21/11 04:53 AM.