No, he didn't hit the nail on the head. It's still disrespectful and doesn't make sense.

If you're homosexual, the act IS BEING homosexual. That "murderer" example was inadequate. If you're a murderer, or "crazy killer", the act is KILLING people. That's a wrong doing, a sin. If you're homosexual... There's no act... The act, if any, IS BEING a homosexual. So, basically, you're just saying homosexuality is wrong in different words.

Plus, why would God see homosexuality as a sin? That's like saying if you have long hair, it's a sin; if you have short hair, you're a sin; if you're white, it's a sin; if you're black, it's a sin. God gave us the right to FREE WILL. So this whole arguement with it being a sin is a CONTRADICTION. You're just saying this 'cause you're not homosexual and it's something you're not. You just can't except something that you don't respect or agree with. There's a term for that: homophobic.

You just seem to be too ignorant, immature, and frightened to except something you're not and don't agree with.

And I'm not directing this towards you, OS, or you, DV. This is directed towards ANYONE who used this "sin" front as an excuse to shun homosexuality.