I may be wrong but isn't Melky a center fielder as well as Granderson? Even with the critics of Granderson, I would take him over Cabrera any day. Not too many guys can hit 20-30 homeruns from the leadoff spot. And as far as Nick Johnson, I kind of agree. I don't know why they didn't just resign Matsui at DH.

But seriously, with the lineup you have for the Yankees how can you complain about anything they do at this point?