Originally Posted By: klydon1
Originally Posted By: Sicilian Babe

I also read "The Scarlet Letter" to help my daughter in English class. I try to read whatever she's required to read so that we can discuss it. Why oh why is this book still required?? I appreciate the theme of a repressive and sexist society and how wrong it is, but is there no other book that can give the kids that?? UGH!


I love this book, and relaize I'm in the minority. But if I had to make a "Mt. Rushmore" list of the four greatest American novels, I'd include it. I thought it artfully weaved multiple strong themes in a compelling manner. I actually find that most people consider it dull and drawn out. So I may be a little weird.



Gotta go with Klyd on this. And I agree, the majority is with babe. I know since I remember I was one of the few students in class who actually loved it. They threw rocks at me. (ok not really..) but what I love most is the way Hawthorne use the english language with such richness that every description is so vivid. I wouldnt include it in the mount rushmore tho.

My "Mount Rushmore" of American novels:

1) The Great Gatsby
2) Moby-Dick
3) Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
4) The Grapes of Wrath

Had to leave out quite a few excellent novels, but I think that's my Mount Rushmore.


Anyone else willing to share his/her Mt.Rushmore of American novels ?


"Come out and take it, you dirty, yellow-bellied rat, or I'll give it to you through the door!"

- James Cagney in "Taxi!" (1932)