In that scene, Vito looks about 30, Roth is about 17 or 18. But, in the Havana birthday scene, Roth's cake shows him celebrating his 67th birthday in December 1958, which gives him a birth year of 1891, same as Vito. That would be consistent with Frankie saying "your father did business with Hyman Roth," and Roth telling Michael how he and Vito "ran molasses into Canada," etc.[/quote]

Sorry, but eh....Hyman Roth does not look 67 years old! More like 87.