2009 AL

Guaranteed: Mariano Rivera, Ichiri Suzuki (arguably the best player of this decade)
Probably: Derek Jeter*
At this rate: Joe Mauer, Tori Hunter

2009 NL

Guaranteed: Trevor Hoffman
At this rate: Albert Pujols, Prince Fielder, Ryan Howard, Johan Santana.

*=Before some of you knee-jerk YES, consider that Don Mattingly (former AL MVP) and Alan Trammell aren't in the HOF.