I agree. Syesha definitely brought it, and they ripped her apart for singing a song from Fantasia. When she announced that she was going to take on Fantasia, after dipping into the Sacred Whitney Well last week, I knew she was going to be screwed. The judges do NOT like that.

I did not like Carly at all. I thought she was horrible. And I agree that David Cook was a disappointment.

Although I think that Kristy Lee does better with country, she was still completely out of tune on half the verses. YIKES.