Although I would probably swap David C. and Carly on your list, I agree with the rest of your grades. I just can't seem to get emotional about any of the performances. None of them have said WOW to me. When I think of some of the performances from last year (Melinda's "Home", Jordin's "I'll Walk Alone", LaKisha's "And You're Gonna Love Me", or Blake's "Time of the Season), I'm still waiting for one of these contestants to make me sit up and take notice. With the exception of a couple of David C's performances, they haven't.