I agreed w/ the judges more this week, but still I disagreed on a few (I didn't like Yesterday as much as they did)
A DavidA (The Long & Winding Road) - BRILLIANT
B+ DavidC (Day Tripper)
B Carly (Blackbird)
B Amanda (Back in the USSR)
B- Brooke (Here Comes the Sun)
B- Chikezie (I've Just Seen a Face)
C+ Michael (A Day in the Life)
C Jason (Michelle)
C- Ramiele (I Should've Known Better)
C- Syesha (Yesterday)
D- Kristy (Hide Your Love Away) - HIDEOUS
I watched it w/ my best friend who's the biggest Beatles fan on the planet, and a musician. He also "hates" everything and everyone, including Idol.
But he was so impressed by D.A. that he wanted to see it again. "I've been trying to hate this kid, but he's gonna win it - he's great". I actually FELT his conviction, and it was a beautifully sung song.
Kristy needs to go.