That was one of the best Idol shows in a long time. The guys were all decent at minimum, and some of them were very good.

I loved David H., David Cook and Jason Castro, who sang one of my favorite songs in the world. I thought that the three of them were head and shoulders above the rest in vocals and/or creativity.

I think that David A. will be fine. He was good, but not great. Luke, Michael, Chikezie and Danny ranged from meh (Luke) to fairly good (Chikezie).