That was one of the best Idol shows in a long time. The guys were all decent at minimum, and some of them were very good.

I loved David H., David Cook and Jason Castro, who sang one of my favorite songs in the world. I thought that the three of them were head and shoulders above the rest in vocals and/or creativity.

I think that David A. will be fine. He was good, but not great. Luke, Michael, Chikezie and Danny ranged from meh (Luke) to fairly good (Chikezie).


President Emeritus of the Neal Pulcawer Fan Club