I WAS thinking of I'll Never Smile Again! Does this mean I'm getting old??

The judges were bizarre. None of their criticisms made any sense. Randy loved the beginning of one song, Simon liked the end. When the poor girl (not sure which one) tried to be diplomatic about accepting their critique, Simon said, "How are you going to listen to it all? If I liked one half and Randy liked the other half, who are you going to listen to?"