JT without a doubt. First of all, he's at least part Sicilian. Second of all, I've had a crush on him since I was about 13!

My sister-in-law loves Sam Elliott, from when he played Chance on some TV cowboy show. My brother used to put on my nephew's toy holster and cowboy hat and announce, C'mon, honey! It's Chance!! But she felt that there was something lacking.

Edited to Add: But I would have to put Kurt Russell on my List, although he is getting a little old. And to make it fit into the Sports genre, I'll top my list with Derek Jeter.