Chicken Little II (Sanjaya) safe over AJ??
Ahh, there's always next week.....

No, but she certainly looked like she bought herself some other new assets! OMG!! Those things scared me when they came out on my TV.

Well, that I didn't mind...

Hope they invent 3D TVs in my lifetime

Antonella makes it through despite controversy!
(Maybe that helped her! )

Leslie no shocker to leave...

PS - Nick and Alaina also history.

Too bad, I liked Pedro...

Well I guess she can afford it now

Well, IMHO, Nick and AJ didn't deserve to get voted off yet, and neither did Leslie. Brandon and Sanjaya were WAY worse. I don't think that any of them have the potential to win, but AJ was just getting interesting. Plus, he was the only contestant shorter than Ryan Seacrest.

And while Alaina should have gone last week, Antonella deserved to go before Leslie. Antonella and her eye-rolling and snotty comments about Jennifer Hudson (like she compares) were just too much. She's a snotty, snooty, untalented biyatch.

The Pickler looked like she was about 40 years old with that hair-do and make-up. But I wasn't looking at her face all that much, anyways...

I was surprised to see A.J and Nick voted off. A.J did VERY well on Tuesday, and Nick had a nice voice, as well. Getting eliminated before Sanjaya is just ludicrous.

Alana wasn't that great, so I wasn't surprised she got voted off. I was disappointed that Leslie was eliminated, though (again, not shocked, though.)

It's contestants like Sanjaya and Antonella that give me the false hope that I could make it on this show. Because I can't sing, either...

***EDIT***

SB called Antonella a biyatch! That's the greatest thing I've read all day!

Picked it up from my daughter.

I noticed that this group of contestants are emotional when they said who had to go home. Even Sundance was crying.

I thought that Jared was going home when Ryan had him come on stage with him. But he was safe.

I can't believe Alaina forgot the words to her song. I bet Antonella and her smart ass mouth will stick around for a few weeks. Just like Sanjaya will also.

Sundance! Sundance!! SUNDANCE!!!

I agree with all of you - although the voteoffs didn't surprise me, they're still pretty disappointing. DialIdol not only had Sanjaya not in the bottom 2, it shows that he's pretty far from it (in 2nd place) so I think we'll be seeing him around for awhile. AJ didn't deserve to go just yet.

As for the girls, getting her pics on the internet was the best thing that could have happened to Antonella.

It was funny having Pickle back. She resembled Dolly Parton in more ways than one.

The line of questioning from Ryan went completely over her head.

I paraphrase:

Ryan: "So with your success, have you bought anything with your money?"
Pickle: "Shoes."
Ryan: "Is that all???"

Actually that went over my head, too...

The spider sushi bit seemed a little contrived, I don't know - how can someone be that stupid??

What is with Sanjaya? Why is he doing a really bad hula?? Why is his hairdresser channeling David Cassidy in his Partridge Family days?? And why did he suck like a Hoover? I really like that John Mayer song, and I may never want to hear it again after that.

I thought the guys were sucky again, even the better ones...

Blake and the two Chrisses were good. Other than that, can they all just go home now?? Phil, grow your hair back. Your baldness and your scary eyes are NOT flattering. Simon's right. Sundance, you should also grow some of your hair back because, with shorter hair, your head looks roughly the size of a parade float. Brandon and Jared are interchangeably forgettable and that's it.

Should go: Sundance, Phil, Brandon and Sanjaya, to make room for more of the girls.

What was Chris Sligh's secret? I was on the phone and missed it. Phil was bad tonight but I don't think he should go home yet. Sanjaya and his hula straighted hair and Brandon should find something else to do. Maybe Jared should go back to playing basketball.

Sundance reminds me of the singer Meatloaf. Well let's see who they vote off.

Tonight's episode was VERY underwhelming.

Blake was exceptional, and I love the different vibe he brings to the competition. Chris Sligh was pretty good tonight, as well.

The rest of them were bleh.

I'm rooting for the girls this season.

Last night's episode stunk. B-O-R-I-N-G.

They shouldn't do a top 12 this year. They should probably do a top 9 since there are probably only 9 singers that I care to listen to any further.

Mig - Chris Sligh's secret was that he was bald a couple of years ago.

Dial Idol has Sundance and Phil in the bottom two but the statistics show that no one is really safe. Good - send all of them home.

Once again, the girls were amazing. Thank goodness for some sacrificial lambs like Haley, otherwise who would you vote off?? Other than the nightmare that is Antonella, I mean.

Melinda and Lakisha are in a class by themselves, followed closely by Stephanie, Sabrina and then Jordin. Melinda was absofreakinlutely amazing tonight. And I love when the judges tell these singers not to take on Whitney, but I guess there was no need to tell Lakisha that tonight.

I can't help but like Gina, even though she's not even close to the best singer. She's a bit of a toughie, and they've never had a female rocker.

I thought they were all great except for that girlz gone wild Antonella. I got the feeling that Simon don't like her to well. Lakisha was amazing once again.

Other than Antonella I don't know who should go home .

My...what a DRAMATIC difference from last night. The girls completely blew the guys out of the water. Seriously, I wish American Idol would drop their policy of "6 guys, 6 girls" and just put through the ones that got the most votes, period. I can tell you, more than likely, 3 or 4 of the guys would be cut tomorrow. As is, though, I'm predicting Haley and Antonella being eliminated. For the guys, its a crapshoot, really.

Lakisha and Melinda gave me goosebumps tonight. I said a few weeks ago that nobody stood out for me this season. I'm glad that I was proven wrong. Both their performances were absolutely incredible.

This show is so much more enjoyable when they actually have good singers on. Singing competition - go figure!

I join the chorus singing the praises of Melinda and Lakisha. They are really distancing themselves away from everyone.

Dial Idol has Haley and Stephanie going tonight. Unfortunate for Stephanie. As for Antonella, you could just see the judges throwing up their hands in frustration.

"I wish... I just wish you were a better singer." - knowing full well she's going to stay around for awhile.

It is unfortunate for Stephanie or Sabrina, who I think may also be in danger. Haley deserves to go, although she's adorable. As said, it IS a singing competition. However, it's really not. It's a reality show, and it has to have its drama in order to entertain, otherwise we would have seen the likes of Chris Daughtry, LaToya London, Jennifer Hudson, and Elliot Yamin go on to win rather than being voted off. IMHO, they were all better singers than those that lasted longer in the competition.

It's also unfortunate that all you have to do to stay in a singing competition when you can't sing is be one of those girlz gone wild and post pictures on the internet. Maybe Sanjaya should do that huh?

When it was announced that Antonella was going home, I says to meself, "OK, now this is what I'm talking about. America has finally woken up."

Then Haley makes it over Sabrina.

And Sanjaya makes it over both Jared and Sundance.

America...WHAT THE F*CK?!?!

Tonight's show was a complete and total travesty. How could they have sent Sabrina home?? UGH!! As annoyed as I am by Sanjaya, at least I'll never have to listen to An"ho"nella again.

It is just WRONG that Sabrina went home. Randy thought so to. What is wrong with the world when someone that can sing her heart out has to leave and someone that has no singing talent stays like Sanjaya. Does he have pic's on the net to?

Damn, too bad I saw this before actually watching the results show... I forgot...

...but firstly, obviously they all have *some* talent enough to warrant their Top 20 status. And they do, all, have enough talent and/or potential.

But truthfully, besides LaKisha and Melinda... and perhaps Blake on the boys' side... no one really stands out as anyone special (as a vocal artist). Besides that handful. BUT - regardless of performances until now, they obviously got to this point for a reason. They all have good voices.

But we only need 1 American Idol. LaKisha or Melinda should win. I think Blake is awesome, and is my boy favorite. The others, well, they're gonna drop every week - and rightfully so, cuz those are the rules. And it doesn't really matter -- in the grand scheme of things -- in which order they drop. They're gonna go anyway!

Although JG is correct, I wanted Sanjaya off my TV screen. He looks like a nice kid and all, but he's completely out of his league. This show is so much more enjoyable when the singers are actually good and with these subpar (comparatively) singers making it through, the show loses something. Sabrina was in the Top 5 singers I think (not just girls, but overall) and should have been around for awhile.

Nice thing they're doing with their charity initiatives in Africa and here in the U.S. I hope people vote up a storm.