A few posts ago I said I thought Michigan deserves a rematch. Now I'm changing my mind. Why would a Michigan win catapult them to the #1 ranking in a rematch? Using this half-assed BCS formula, what if Michigan beat OSU in the title game by 1 point? Who would be #1 then - would there have to be a 3rd game to "break the tie?" I think Michigan had their shot, they lost, and now it's time for another team to step up.

The only way I can justify a rematch is if USC, Florida, and Arkansas all get a 2nd loss.