You are correct.
----------------------------------------
BONASERA (as he leaves the room)
Grazie, Godfather.
VITO CORLEONE
Prego.
(then, to Tom Hagen, after Bonasera leaves the room)
Ah, give this to ah, Clemenza. I want reliable people; people that aren't gonna be carried
away. I'm mean, we're not murderers, despite of what this undertaker says.
------------------------------------
Perhaps he was a member of Clemenza's crew 10 years earlier. In any case, either this is an error or somethign that should have been better explained.